It is Your Choice to Be One of the Elect, so Choose!

For centuries theologians have debated Predestination v Free-Will.  It can be a hotly debated topic and one that can be very divisive.  I don’t mind the debate, but I DO NOT want to be divisive.

According to John Calvin,

“Predestination we call the eternal decree of God, by which He has determined in Himself, what He would have to become of every individual of mankind. For they are not all created with a similar destiny; but eternal life is foreordained for some and eternal death for others. Every man, therefore, being created for one or the other of these ends, we say he is predestinated either to life or to death.” – Institutes, Book III, Ch. XXI, Sec. 5.

The Beginning Point

To unravel this question, I believe you must begin with God.

One of the incommunicable attributes of God is His omnipresence.  This means that God is at all places in all time at the same time.  In other words, God is.

Yahweh is God’s name.  It is how God referred to Himself with talking to Moses in the burning bush.  The name means “I am.” (Exodus 3:14)

This doctrine is described for us in several places through out Scripture.  My favorite passage related to His omnipresence is Psalms 139.  In verses 7 – 8, the Psalmists ask where one can go to get away from God.  He recognizes that no matter where he goes, God is there.

The omnipresence of God is a critical component in understand the relationship between Predestination and Free-Will.

Which came first?

The abbreviated version of the debate is based on the idea of it being EITHER  we were either predestined and our salvation was determined by a game of pick by God in eternity past OR we pick God if he wins the contest of religious systems.

It is almost always defined as either . . . or.  Which came first, the predestined or the free will?

Opposite Sides of the Same Door

I believe that we are actually dealing with a BOTH . . . AND . . . scenario.  Here’s how.

If God is omnipresent, this means that ALL of time exist as the present with God.  When the Holy Spirit pulled at my heart to accept Christ as my Savior, that was the eternal moment of election.  It was that moment.  It wasn’t something that took place in eternity past that has finally arrived 10,000 years after the election.  The invitation from the Spirit of God was the election.

God choosing me and my choosing God are the same event.  I view the event as a linear progression through time, but with God it simply is.  My past and future are present with God.

I Am Elected So I Choose

This is why God can declare things to be.  It’s not because He is looking into the future and therefore knows what will happen.  It is happening.  Everything is happening.  The creation, the crucifixion, my Salvation and the resurrection of the saints are events that are happening.  With God, these are not past or future events.

My Election was not an event in the past.  My election by the sovereignty of God and my choice to accept his gift on my own free-will are the same event, just a different perspective.

The Scriptures Agree

Look at the progression in Romans 8:29-30.  Those who He predestined, he called, and those who He called, he justified; those he justified, he glorified.  Paul is communicating the fact that the event of being predestined (election) is also the event of justification (salvation) and the event of glorification (sanctification).  This is a singular event from the perspective of God.

In Ephesians 1, Paul communicates the same story.  We are predestined according to the purpose of His will.  We are predestined and completed according to His will at the same event.

We were not chosen in the past and offered salvation in the present to be glorified in the future.  That is a linear perspective limited by our humanity.  From God’s perspective, we are chosen and offered salvation and glorified NOW.

What do you think?  Do you agree or disagree?  Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments below.

2 thoughts on “It is Your Choice to Be One of the Elect, so Choose!

  1. Hey Alan…I agree with what you are saying, but I wonder if that would be the true calvinistic position? Saying that time is always the present with God is absolutely correct as He is actually the creator of time…for us, we see past, present and future, but for God, He sees it all at the same moment…having said that, I believe from everything that I have studied and from every debate (friendly!) I have had with “calvinists”, that you position is not what I have heard before…

  2. Mike, I think the fundamental element of the Predestination/Free Will discussion is directly tied to the idea that God made some for eternal salvation and others for eternal damnation. I think this predicates that idea that before the foundations of the world, God chose some for salvation and others for damnation. In my opinion, this is the hinging point of the discussion. Am I PRE-destined without any ‘free-will’ to choose or not? I think that the predestined that Paul describes in Romans is directly connected to my free-will to choose. They are the same event, not separate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *